By Jerome A. Cohen
This article helps put flesh on the bare bones of the initial announcement of the unprecedented secret, anonymous HK “hotline” for reporting suspected NSL violations to Hong Kong’s new secret police. For the first week of implementation, harvesting an average of 1,400 pieces of information per day seems to be a promising start for the Mainland-dominated national security unit.
There is evident Hong Kong Government interest in seeing whether this local equivalent of the former East German “Stasi” secret police “hotline” might soon equal or surpass the “hotline” HK police established last year for tips concerning alleged acts of violence, which is now up to 3,000 tips per day!
Yet this HK secret police innovation need not look to the practice of the discredited and overthrown East German regime. As the report points out, the PRC’s Ministry of State Security (MSS), which controls the new HK unit, has been successfully running a similar operation throughout the Mainland since 2017. However, that institution has apparently been so troubled by the receipt of many “malicious reports” that it issued a warning in April that such anonymous accusations could result in “legal consequences”. Nevertheless, the MSS does not want to discourage would-be tipsters and has begun to pay cash rewards to reliable informers. It would be good to know the criteria for compensating informers.
I wonder how long it will be before the HK counterpart offers similar cash rewards and follows another MSS precedent by establishing “a reporting platform” like the one the MSS established in the Mainland soon after it began operating the national “hotline”.